Professional Insurance Programs



Based on 18 reviews
Kevin Nitz
Kevin Nitz
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I recently had the pleasure of working with Professional Insurance Programs, specifically Jake Rehm and Sam Steinmetz. Their promptness and thoroughness in handling my insurance needs were outstanding. They went above and beyond, ensuring every detail was covered and every question was answered. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for exceptional insurance services.
Progressive Dental
Progressive Dental
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
We have had nothing but excellent service from Professional Insurance Programs. Both on the business side and personal side. I would highly recommend them for any and all insurance services. Sam Steinmetz and Christine Nadolski are very attentive and they make any changes necessary far less painful than other insurance companies we've worked with in the past. A++
Jason Cooke
Jason Cooke
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I have been working with Sam for a while now. He has always been very helpful with finding the best options. He always gets back to me as soon as possible and is very knowledgeable. Overall very happy with Professional Insurance Program and would recommend them.
gail and bob d gail and bob d
gail and bob d gail and bob d
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Sam and PIP have managed my professional and personal insurance needs, several properties in two states and multiple vehicles. Sam’s response is excellent. Thank you
Annie Hart
Annie Hart
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I am so pleased that we moved our home and auto insurance over to Professional Insurance Programs. Sam Steinmetz and Ben Erickson saved us money and found us the right insurance for our needs. Whenever I call with a question or problem I know I have an insurance team that is working for me to resolve it. They both are very professional and knowledgeable. Their response time back to me proves that I don't have to handle this on my own. Very happy customers! This year my husband retired and we needed to find supplemental insurance. I reached out to Christine Nadolski and she came over to the house and walked us through all our options. This was a great experience for both my husband and for me. I feel like I had enough information to pick the right insurance for his needs. Again very happy customers
Paul Ostertag
Paul Ostertag
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I have used Professional Insurance programs for both my business and personal insurance needs for over 20 years. I just changed coverage on one of my vehicles. For my personal insurance I most often deal with Sam, who is very knowledgeable and easy to reach. Customer service is top notch. I would highly recommend PIP for any of your insurance needs.
Alan Schwartzstein
Alan Schwartzstein
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
PIP has provided prompt service over the years I have been a client. Sam replies in a timely manner and follows through with our insurance issues for home, vehicle and umbrella needs. He keeps us notified of changes and opportunities to improve coverage and save premium dollars.
David Schoenberger
David Schoenberger
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Sam and the rest of the team at Professional Insurance Programs offer some of the best customer service you’ll find today. They took care of my insurance needs in a quick, reassuring way. I can rest easy knowing my hard-earned assets are covered. I definitely plan to stick with them for my continued insurance needs! Thank you all!
linda prehn
linda prehn
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Sam, is great! Responds quickly and shops the best rates for us. Have not had any issues with customer service or claims. Highly recommend!!!!
Monica Van Aken
Monica Van Aken
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I am a putz. The kind of person who can't find thier insurance policy, who never remembers when to renew... I love the fact that I never have to think about anything working with Sam at PIP. My insurance coverage is first rate, Sam makes sure I am covered in the most reasonable and conservative manner, he sends timely reminders, gives suggestions for coverage and saving money; I find his group to be reliable. I would never switch or use anyone else. He picks up the phone, answers my calls, and is always a little more helpful than I expect him to be.



Miranda P., DDS


Paula C., DDS


Christine, We want to thank you for the fast, professional, and extremely kind service you provided us. Healthcare itself is a stressful situation not to mention dealing with the insurance part of it. Your guidance in our time of need provided great comfort.  Thank you very much!

Eric Z., DDS


I had nothing but the finest customer service working with my personal representative from Professional Insurance Programs. As a small business owner, I have no HR department to manage our health insurance plan. Christine Nadolski has gone above and beyond to literally “hold my hand” through the process to ensure my employees’ health insurance needs are being met. I couldn’t have done this without Christine and her company by my side!

Erin H, DVM


Let’s be honest.  Dealing with insurance is no fun.  Sam has been there to solve any and every issue that has come up, allowing me to be productive at my work.  He is a rock star in customer service and a true pleasure to work with.

Tim C., DDS


Paul Allen did an excellent job in what turned out to be a complicated renewal of our professional liability and cyber policies. He offered to help us get quotes for next year’s renewals. Paul was courteous, professional, and responsive to our needs.



I recently have had the pleasure of working with Jacob Rehm. He is one of the very few people that I have worked with during my practice acquisition that has gone above and beyond and has exceeded all of my expectations. Jacob is very knowledgeable and detailed. Jacob responded very quickly to any and all of my questions. It was and is still an absolute pleasure to work with him. I am certain you find great value in Jacob. 

Jill C., DDS


I had “my guy” for my Insurance needs right in my practice. Because of an auto accident, I had the opportunity to work with Professional Insurance Programs – part of our own WDA network.  They reviewed all my policies, asked questions and discovered what I was missing.  Phenomenal service, tremendous financial savings and even more importantly, stronger coverages!  They saved me a bundle of money on my home, auto, umbrella and boat insurance!  Sam is very responsive, he has helped me with many different policy changes and is literally an email/phone call away.  You want your patients to think of you like family, not just another “customer” or number. That is how I feel, working with Professional Insurance Programs.

Pete H.,  DDS


Christine Nadolski has been a fantastic resource for our health insurance over the years with all of our very different needs as a business. She goes above and beyond to answer my questions and helps in every way possible. She is very quick to respond to any calls or emails I’ve sent her way, which is appreciated by someone like me who likes to “check things off the list”. We will definitely reach back out to her when we need her again! Thank you, Christine!

Brittany W, Practice Manager


I can not say enough about how blessed the PIP and WDA members are in having Linda Welker working for them! she goes out of her way and the extra mile to find the best quality insurance for the lowest price! Do not lose her! Keep her there! I would hire her in a minute and give her a bonus for how she works! PIP has been great for me! Thank you!

Larry N., DDS


We were away from our home for a few days, and when we returned, there was water gushing out of the wall kitchen wall, onto our beautiful wood flooring and into the basement.  This was a major disaster and turned out to be a very large claim, over $150K of damage!  Professional Insurance Programs were involved from the very beginning, working with me and our insurance carrier.  I am happy they took the time to ask a lot of questions, and learn about our needs upfront.  They are both caring people, and professionals, I could not be happier with the outcome! 

S.J., MD


Professional Insurance Programs made finding insurance and signing up for an appropriate plan incredibly easy!  In a world of insurance that can be very confusing, Professional Insurance Programs made it seamless. I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for a change in their insurance!

Caitlin P.


Professional Insurance Programs really does a good job! As you know my son and his girlfriend were involved in a serious accident with significant injuries, and we needed to file a claim. I wanted to “thank you” again for being there for us throughout the entire claims process. When I needed help, you got involved. You helped answer our questions, gave us direction when we needed it and stayed actively involved with us for over a year while it was all being sorted out with the claims adjustor. Financially speaking, everything was covered to my satisfaction and I have no complaints. I am so grateful you were on our side, keep up the great work!

Dr. Timothy K.


Chris was so great to work with! We all know what a pain switching insurances can be… but Chris made it a dream! She always promptly answered phone calls and emails, and was a joy to work with! I would highly recommend Professional Insurance Programs!

Jessica, Dental Practice Manager


Working with Sam thus far has been fabulous. He is responsive, attentive and takes care of concerns and needs within a timely manner. I would absolutely recommend his service to anyone!

Jaynee J.


I am a new client of Professional Insurance Programs.  Their effort and results more than met our standards and expectations.  I asked him to review and update all my personal insurance needs which included several policies.  He was very prompt, thorough, available and achieved an excellent result.  My experience was outstanding! I can recommend Professional Insurance Programs very highly and without any reservations.

Gayle and Michael M., MD


Professional Insurance Programs personal lines team has always been very helpful, and caring when it comes to processing claims we have had to make over the years.  But what impresses me the most is their quick, timely and accurate replies to my questions or concerns.  I know whenever I have a question, they will get back to me with an informative and friendly response. I’m very happy with PIP! 

Aaron Q.


Sam Steinmetz was courteous, responsive, and very helpful during my insurance renewal process earlier this month.  He answered all my questions, put through all the changes in my family circumstances and processed my premium payment.  I enjoy working with Sam.

Patrick G.


We reviewed the final quote together and are very comfortable with the proposal.  Cost savings is a factor, Most importantly, the deciding factor for us was the excellent job you have done of providing us with clear information and communicating effectively with us without being pushy.  Your ratings for customer service are well deserved.  At the same time I reached out to you, I inquired of 5 additional companies/agents and you provided customer service that surpassed all the others. 

Marla, DVM


I want to let you know what an efficient and professional job Christine Nadolski does with our health insurance. She has been helping me for several years and I’m always impressed with her prompt, patient and friendly manner. She has been willing to go the extra mile for us on several occasions and we appreciate her very much. she is such a pleasure to work with. 

Kim M., Office Manager


A SHOUT OUT to Professional Insurance Programs.  They helped me tremendously throughout this commercial policy flood insurance process.  They went above and beyond to make sure we really needed the elevation certificate, looking for what may be a less expensive option and what would be best for us. The team is rockstars, a pleasure to work with, and very responsive to the client’s best interests.

Emily B.  Office Manager


We had six separate insurance policies (home, umbrella, three auto policies and renter’s insurance for our daughter’s college apartment), we thought we’d see if working with Professional Insurance Programs could save us some money. Well, not only could PIP save us several hundred dollars a year, they were also able to roll everything into one policy, with one bill and one due date – a big plus for convenience. The team is great to work with and always ready to answer questions. We are now spending less money for more insurance and feel really good about working with PIP!

Chris S.


In this wacky world, getting wackier, it is so nice to have a rep., like Michelle who communicates and is so accessible.

Judy K.


We have had various changes to our policies this year. Sam ensured everything was adjusted accurately and was extremely responsive to our questions and the changes!

Ryan G., CPA


The Professional Insurance Programs team informed me that my original homeowner’s quote had gone up after the insurance carrier completed their home inspection.  After talking the matter over, they contacted the insurance carrier and discovered there was a square footage discrepancy.  They contacted the city assessor’s office, verifying the home square footage he used was correct and then challenged what the carrier used after the home inspection.  After seeing the assessor report he provided they agreed to change the square footage amount back to the original premium amount.  This level of customer support separates them from the average agent, and it is duly noted by me.  

Ann M., MD


Thanks to Professional Insurance Programs for solving all my personal insurance needs in a courteous and professional manner. Not only did they solve an unwarranted cancellation problem, but the final solution also saved significant premium dollars.

Thomas R., DDS


We received our quotes the same day, were explained every step of the process and gave me a timeline.  They were so friendly and knowledgeable that I was at ease throughout the whole process.  I have the utmost respect for the Professional Insurance Programs team.  In a time when it seems there is less and less compassion or concern for the “little guy” the team’s demeanor proved that there are great people out there.

Patti S.,  Janesville


Professional Insurance Programs made the entire process painless and enjoyable.

Rick A., JD


Professional Insurance Programs has been very helpful to me and my family with our insurance needs.  It has been a pleasure working with them.  The team is very professional, thorough and accurate.  And I especially appreciate the fact that they have gone out of their way to help us during non-business hours.

Pat G., CPA


Professional Insurance Programs is a knowledgeable and dependable insurance agency. Our situation was complex requiring five different types of policies for quoting. As we moved forward through the process they were extremely patient and prompt in making the many changes we asked for. We are very pleased not only with the reputable insurance company that now holds our policies but also with the financial savings we benefited from recommendations.

Sandy & John R., DDS


The Professional Insurance Programs team was extremely professional throughout the process and helped save me $500 per year. I suspect that he can do the same for you.

Richard B. D.D.S., M.S. (Endodontist for 36 years)


Professional Insurance Programs was very easy to work with!  They got us the best coverage for my home and auto insurance at a competitive price as well. They made the transition seamless and I would highly recommend them to friends and colleagues!

Kathleen C., DDS


Professional Insurance Programs personal lines team, you are doing so much to help my mom and I can’t thank you enough!  You have made this process much easier for her and this would have been a nightmare without you.  Thanks for all the hard work, ideas and communications!

Randy L


I enjoyed working with Professional Insurance Programs from quoting to having the policies issued. They were very responsive, I feel like I was at the “top of the pile” throughout the process with timely emails.

James H., CPA


I highly recommend working with Professional Insurance Programs. Not only are they efficient and effective at what they do, they truly care about finding the best options for you. I appreciate the knowledge and work ethic that their team has. All my questions were answered and coverage was obtained immediately.

Suzanne B. Medical Associate


I just moved to Wisconsin and didn’t have any leads on a good insurance agent and found Professional Insurance Programs through the internet. I could not have asked for a more knowledgeable thorough group to walk me through the entire process. They showed me my options, didn’t give me pressure to go with the most expensive, understood my needs for saving money but also staying safely insured. I am happy with Professional Insurance Programs and will be using them when I need to renegotiate my insurance or insure something new later on when my needs change.

Ren L. – Business Consultant